With the rise of bubbly and flavored water options, many health-conscious consumers wonder what’s best for hydration and wellness. As a flavored water company, we’re often asked – are sparkling or flavored waters healthier? Let’s compare the nutrition science.
Flavored Waters Add Fruit Aroma, Not Sugar
Flavored waters do not actually contain any essences, extracts or flavorings dissolved into the water itself. They are pure plain water with no additions. They contain no added sugars or calories. The natural plant extracts provide fragrance to excite the nose and flavor buds.
The Science Behind Flavored Waters
How do these flavorings make plain water taste like juicy peach or refreshing mint when there's no real fruit? Let's explore the science behind it.
Flavor compounds interact with our olfactory system to stimulate scent receptors in the nose. Even though the solid fruit isn't touching our tongues, our noses can still detect the fruity aroma from dissolved flavor chemicals. This tricks the brain into tasting the expected flavors.
For example, peach flavored water contains trace amounts of gamma-decalactone, an aroma compound also naturally present in fresh peaches. Though no real peach is added, our nose still picks up the familiar, juicy peach scent. This stimulates the taste bud sensations we associate with eating actual peaches.
Flavor chemists carefully identify key aromatic compounds in real foods and beverages. They then skillfully recreate the scent profiles through precise formulations while eliminating sugars, acids, and calories. This produces essence mixtures that provide satisfying tastes and aromas without downsides like tooth decay or weight gain.
So next time you drink a flavored water, remember it's the artful use of aromatics and scent chemistry that produces the taste experience. The water is simply a odorless, neutral medium for delivering pleasurable flavors to your nose and delighting your senses, without any hidden health risks.
Sparkling Water Has Carbonation, Not Nutrients
Sparkling water is simply water infused with carbon dioxide gas under pressure, creating the signature bubbles. The carbonation makes it more acidic with a pH between 3-4. Sparkling waters can be plain or flavored with natural or artificial essences. Flavored versions contain zero calories while unflavored ones like club soda have added minerals. Some bottled sparkling waters are naturally carbonated from their mineral content while others are manually carbonated.
When it comes to pure hydration, research indicates carbonation doesn't reduce sparkling water's hydration potential. Our kidneys filter out excess carbonic acid while the water content hydrates normally. Studies found no difference in urine output or fluid retention compared to still water. However, carbonation makes sparkling water more acidic, contributing to tooth enamel erosion with excessive drinking over time according to some dentists.
The Verdict: Flavored Water Has an Edge
While neither has sugars, flavored waters edge out sparkling due to the water remains 100% pure H20. The greater acidity of sparkling water from added CO2 is also harsher on tooth enamel.
Of course, plain pure water remains the healthiest hydration source. But for an appealing flavor sensation without sweeteners or calories, flavored water with aroma compounds is superior to fizzy carbonated beverages in terms of ingredient composition.
So for flavor-seeking fitness buffs and natural health enthusiasts, flavored waters made with real plant extracts offer health advantages over trendy sparkling waters. Let the aroma of fruits hydrate you!
Leave a comment
All comments are moderated before being published.
This site is protected by hCaptcha and the hCaptcha Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.